These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (2024)

TL;DR

Our favorite lip gloss is the Bobbi Brown Crushed Oil-Infused Gloss. It’s creamy and lightweight, the formula is moisturizing and non-sticky, and the shades are buildable. It’s beautiful on bare lips or applied on top of lip liner or your favorite lip color. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option that comes in a large shade range, we recommend the NYX Butter Gloss. And if you like the convenience of lipstick but want a hydrating formula with a shiny finish, go for the Tarte Maracuja Juicy Lip Balm.

Forget everything you once knew about lip glosses—modern formulas have traded the sticky, goopy textures of the past for more lightweight, hydrating consistencies. Though they provide the same juicy-looking finish that was popular in the early 2000s, today’s glosses are a heck of a lot more comfortable to wear, including clear, glassy picks and more saturated formulas.

To help you find the best lip gloss (or a few) for you, wetesteddozens of options in our lab facility in NYC and at home in our real lives, evaluating each one based on its formula and feel on the lips, how well it hydrated them, how well it wore, and the shade range. More than a dozen thoroughly impressed us—ranging from drugstore buys to more high-end options—and ahead, we’re sharing the ones we believe are the best around.

Our Top Picks

Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review

What We Like

  • Comfortable, creamy formula

  • Semi-pigmented shades

  • Lightweight

  • Non-sticky

  • Contains moisturizing hyaluronic acid and vitamin c

What to Consider

  • Not ideal for those who want a super high-shine finish

Highlighted Ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, vitamins C and E, botanical oils | Shades: 13 | Size: 6 ml

The very best lip glosses are hydrating and comfortable to wear (in addition to providing the look you want, of course), and this one checks those boxes. Formulated with a blend of nourishing ingredients like hyaluronic acid, vitamins, and botanicals, it feels soft and moisturizing when applied—and it keeps lips feeling quenched for hours on end. Though it’s not the most glassy-looking gloss on this list, it creates a shiny finish and provides a wash of semi-pigmented, healthy-looking color. We loved that this formula is neither goopy nor runny, so it doesn’t feather or bleed into lip lines. It’s lightweight, creamy, and non-sticky, and it layers beautifully over a lip liner or your favorite lip color. If you’re looking for a moisturizing lip gloss that adds an understated shine, we highly recommend this one.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (2)

What We Like

  • Lightweight, creamy texture

  • Buildable pigmentation

  • Keeps lips feeling hydrated

  • Subtle fruity scent

  • Non-sticky

What to Consider

  • Could be a bit more long-wearing

Highlighted Ingredients: Shea butter | Shades: 5 | Size: 9 ml

The original Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb quickly became a fan-favorite in the lip gloss category, so it’s no surprise that this pigmented, non-shimmery version has followed suit. The lightweight, creamy formula is non-sticky and feels pillowy and soft on the lips, and we loved that it kept them feeling hydrated throughout the duration of the test. Some of the shades in the minimal range are more pigmented than others, though they can all be built up for fairly opaque coverage. As the glossy finish faded gradually after a couple of hours, we noticed that the color left behind remained even and intact. We also adore the subtle fruity scent—it’s a nice diversion from vanilla fragrances often featured in lip products. We were impressed with the performance of this gloss and recommend it to anyone looking for a one-and-done product that provides moisture, shine, and color.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (4)

What to Consider

  • Some of the shades need building up

  • Could be more high-shine

Highlighted Ingredients: Hyaluronic acid | Shades: 20 | Size: 5 ml

The large doe-foot applicator reminds us of the one in the Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb, though this drugstore pick is just a fraction of the cost. The applicator picks up enough product to coat the lips without needing to re-dip several times. The formula of this Maybelline Lip Lifter gloss is creamy with a texture that feels akin to a semi-thick gel, and we appreciated that it didn’t feel sticky or overly goopy on the lips. Once applied, it lasts well without bleeding or feathering, and it feels nice and hydrating without being greasy. While we wish the finish delivered a bit more shine and the shades were more consistent in terms of their pigmentation levels, the formula is fantastic, and at such an affordable price, this gloss is hard to beat.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (6)

What We Like

  • Comes in 30+ shades

  • Smooth, creamy consistency

  • Pigmented colors

  • Doesn't bleed or feather

What to Consider

  • Shine fades fairly quickly

  • Could be more hydrating

Highlighted Ingredients: None referenced | Shades: 31 | Size: 8 ml

Another, even more budget-friendly option, this popular pick from NYX has been a staple in the lip gloss category for many years. The creamy, butter-like formula is incredibly smooth and soft. It comes in more than 30 shades, ranging from light and dark nudes to vibrant pinks and berry reds, all of which have buildable pigmentation. In terms of wear and hydration benefits, we think there are more impressive formulas, but all things considered, this affordable option is worth trying, especially if you’re looking for a shiny gloss in a particular color.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (8)

What We Like

  • Wet-looking shine

  • Non-sticky

  • Hydrating formula

  • Feels smooth and comfortable on the lips

What to Consider

  • Could be more long-lasting

Highlighted Ingredients: Apricot kerne, raspberry seed, and rosehip oils | Shades: 13 | Size: 4 ml

With a glossy, gel-like formula, this super comfortable gloss from Tower 28 might as well have its own fan club. People rave about the smooth, non-sticky consistency, how soft it feels on the lips, and most of all, how wildly shiny and glassy the finish is. It comes in a range of milky neutrals and jelly-like pops of color, and we loved how it looked on the lips—it created a smooth wash of color with a wet-looking shine. We also appreciate that it’s formulated with a blend of oils which helps to keep the lips from feeling dry. Though it can feel just the slightest bit tacky as it fades after several hours, generally, you won’t have to think twice about it being thick or sticky. If you like the look of intense shine, this is undoubtedly the lip gloss for you.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (10)

What We Like

  • Lightweight, creamy texture

  • Wears nicely

  • Doesn't bleed or feather

What to Consider

  • Color fades relatively quickly

  • Could be more hydrating

Highlighted Ingredients: Jojoba, almond, and argan oils, shea butter | Shades: 6 | Size: 6.5 ml

If you’re someone who likes to splurge on little luxuries, this lavish lip gloss is perfect for you. The sleek, weighted packaging looks and feels elegant, and the formula feels plush and creamy while remaining comfortable on the lips. Infused with a blend of nourishing oils, like almond and jojoba oil, we found that the formula felt pretty average in terms of hydration (it wasn’t drying but it also wasn’t the most hydrating option), though the creamy consistency was ultra-soft and lightweight on the lips. The shades create a visible but not overpowering wash of color, and a nice shiny finish. We also think this is a great pick for anyone who prefers opting for products with more natural formulations.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (12)

What We Like

  • Not tacky or goopy

  • Wears well

  • Lightweight, creamy formula

  • Colors are buildable

What to Consider

  • Could be more hydrating

  • Finish isn't super shiny

Highlighted Ingredients: Botanical blend | Shades: 5 | Size: 3.8 ml

Sticky gloss haters, raise your hands! Heavy, sticky lip gloss is a makeup pet peeve for so many people, so we’re glad formulas have improved over the years and there are now tons of non-sticky options. Out of the ones we put to the test, this is the pick we recommend the most for those who are sensitive to tacky formulas. It feels like a hybrid between a gloss and a lip balm—it’s smooth, creamy, and lightweight.

Though it didn’t stand out for its hydrating ingredients, it didn’t feel drying to us. It felt creamy and comfortable to wear for hours at a time, and we loved how subtly the color and shine faded. Each shade provides a hint of rosy, wearable color, and we liked how an added layer or two could build up the pigmentation. If you’re looking for a great everyday gloss that you’ll barely even notice on your lips, this is the one for you.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (14)

What We Like

  • Wears well

  • High-shine finish

  • Doesn't bleed or feather

  • A lot of product in the tube

What to Consider

  • Thick, pretty sticky formula

Highlighted Ingredients: Vitamin E | Shades: 12 | Size: 15 ml

Incredibly popular in the early 2000s, this iconic pick from Lancôme remains a favorite—if you can get past the thick, fairly sticky consistency. Yes, it’s thick and definitely more tacky than the other options on this list, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing when you consider that usually, the thicker and more sticky the formula, the longer it lasts on the lips. We found that if you apply a light layer, it provides incredible shine and wears for several hours without needing to reapply it. If you can resist the urge to rub your lips together frequently, it feels smooth and pretty comfortable once applied. The plush texture also helps to blur the appearance of fine lines on the lips, which can lead to a more plump-looking pout. Plus, we appreciate that there’s a ton of product in the tube, so this gloss will last you quite some time.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (16)

What We Like

  • Helps to lock in moisture

  • Smooth, creamy texture

  • High-shine finish

What to Consider

  • Not the most long-lasting

Highlighted Ingredients: Shea and murumuru seed butter | Shades: 6 | Size: 15 ml

If you keep up with popular products on BeautyTok, chances are you’re familiar with this hydrating lip balm that doubles as a gloss. Formulated with a blend of nourishing seed butters, the smooth and creamy texture feels soft and comfortable on the lips. While we didn’t necessarily feel like it added a ton of moisture to the lips, we did find that applying it over a thin lip balm helped to lock in moisture and keep the lips feeling soft for an extended period of time.

It comes in six shades that range from a clear option to a deep berry, and each one coats the lips in a glossy finish. It’s not the most revolutionary glossy lip balm around, but we were quite pleased with the performance and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a hydrating gloss to pop in their bag.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (18)

What We Like

  • Helps to plump the appearance of lip lines

  • Wet-looking finish

  • Long-wearing

  • Unique scent

What to Consider

  • Results could be a bit more dramatic

Highlighted Ingredients: Peptides, cinnamon, ginger | Shades: 5 | Size: 9 ml

Earning our best overall pick in our test of the best lip plumpers, this popular gloss from Patrick Ta continues to impress us. The rich texture delivers dramatic shine and feels ultra-soft on the lips. Unlike a lot of plumping glosses that cause intense tingling or burning, this one feels cooling and a bit tingly for just a few minutes. It’s formulated with cinnamon and ginger to help subtly plump lips, as well as moisturizing peptides to support a healthy skin barrier.

The results aren’t as dramatic as some other lip plumpers on the market, but we did notice some visible improvement in the appearance of lines and lip plumpness when applied. We also appreciate that the shine lasts for several hours and it has a unique cinnamon scent that’s subtle and pleasant. If you’re looking for a painless plumping gloss with a wet-looking finish, we think you’ll be really pleased with this one.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (20)

What We Like

  • 30+ shades to choose from

  • Feels soft and nourishing

  • Wears well

  • Doesn't bleed or feather

What to Consider

  • Can feel a bit thick and heavy on the lips

Highlighted Ingredients: None referenced | Shades: 32 | Size: 4.4 ml

If you’re looking for a specific lip gloss shade, chances are, you’ll meet your match in this extensive line from Pat McGrath. The range features tons of nude shades as well as rich reds, glittery golds, and pretty much everything in between. But aside from the gorgeous colors, we were also impressed with the formula. The texture is on the thicker side which might not be ideal for everyone, but we felt that it still remained comfortable on the lips and the thickness and subtle tackiness helped increase the longevity. It didn’t bleed or feather, it felt soft and nourishing on the lips, and it provided a lustrous shine. Swiping on your favorite shade is the perfect final step in any makeup routine.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (22)

What We Like

  • Provides buildable color payoff

  • Smooth, soft texture

  • Feels slightly cooling

  • Lightweight

  • Line has shimmery and non-shimmery shades

What to Consider

  • Could be more hydrating

Highlighted Ingredients: Shea butter | Shades: 10 | Size: 15 ml

Lip glosses that deliver a nice dose of color can help you cut down on steps in your makeup routine, and this is one of them. One or two swipes of your favorite shade will give your lips a noticeable wash of color with a shiny finish. We enjoy that the range features nudes, pinks, and terracotta hues, and we really love that some shades have fine shimmer in them while others are shimmer-free.

The texture has a medium consistency and feels soft and nourishing on the lips, though we didn’t feel like it was the most hydrating compared to the others we tested. After applying the gloss and waiting for a minute, it creates a subtle cooling sensation (thanks to the peppermint oil in the formula), but it’s not overbearing or painful. The formula feels like a nice, standard lip gloss, but it’s the pigmented shades that make it really stand out.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (24)

What We Like

  • Convenient, mess-free application

  • Smooth, lightweight texture

  • Wears well

  • Buildable pigmentation

  • Moisturizing formula

What to Consider

  • Could be a bit more long-wearing

Highlighted Ingredients: Maracuja and grapeseed oil, goji | Shades: 12 | Size: 2.7 ml

Solid lip glosses have become incredibly popular recently, and this one from Tarte seriously impressed us. Housed in a clicky, pen-like tube, the gloss stick is compact and easy to use. Just a few clicks bring up enough product to evenly coat your lips in the creamy, moisturizing formula. It’s lightweight and comfortable, and we liked that the colors can be built up to provide medium coverage. It offers a juicy, high-shine finish that looks beautiful on bare lips or layered over lip liner. Though it isn’t the most long-wearing gloss on this list, the lightweight formula is easy to re-apply throughout the day and builds without gumming up. If you like the application experience of lipstick but the effect of a gloss, this pick is totally worth checking out.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (26)

What We Like

  • Refreshing, cooling sensation

  • Wet-looking finish

  • Hydrating formula

  • Non-sticky

What to Consider

  • A bit messy to apply

  • Shades could offer a bit more pigmentation

Highlighted Ingredients: Ginger root oil | Shades: 10 | Size: 2.4 ml

Another gloss in stick form, this one is for people who crave a super glassy, wet-looking finish. It’s extremely emollient—which does make it a bit messy to apply from the stick—but it feels incredibly soft and moisturizing on the lips. Once you apply it, the gloss creates a subtle cooling sensation that lasts for about 20 to 30 minutes. It’s plush without feeling sticky or heavy and lasts nicely for a few hours before the shine slowly starts to dissipate. The range features neutral shades and unique pops of color like blue and gray, though they’re all pretty sheer. It’s great for popping on bare lips to add shine and a drop of color, but it also layers beautifully over lip liner or a lip tint.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (28)

What We Like

  • Moisturizing hyaluronic acid formula

  • Provides long-lasting moisture

  • Glossy finish

  • Fragrance-free

What to Consider

  • Can feel a bit heavy and tacky

Highlighted Ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, Kakadu plum blend | Shades: 1 | Size: 15 ml

If you deal with dry lips, then you know that finding products that look nice and glossy while also truly helping to quench dryness isn’t easy. But perhaps your hunt can end here with this gloss-balm hybrid from Glow Recipe. Formulated with hyaluronic acid, plum-derived antioxidants, and raspberry extract, it helps to hydrate the lips and protect them from environmental aggressors. The texture is rich and a bit tacky, though this helps to keep the formula from slipping and sliding around and fading quickly. It’s free from synthetic fragrances which is ideal if you have sensitive skin, and we loved how comfortable and nourishing just a light layer felt. It created a high-shine finish with impressive wear time, and we think this pick is excellent for daytime use or as an overnight lip mask.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (30)

What We Like

  • Hydrating formulation

  • Non-sticky

  • Weightless texture

What to Consider

  • All of the shades look similar on the lips

Highlighted Ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, jojoba oil, shea butter | Shades: 6 | Size: 5 ml

“I was so ready to declare myself completely over lip gloss when this one showed up at my desk and sucked me right back in. My lips look so full and perfect thanks to this delicious, non-sticky formula," raves Bella Cacciatore, news editor at Byrdie. “Most lip oils claim to be hydrating but never actually replace my lip balm, but thanks to the hyaluronic acid in the formula, this one actually keeps my lips happy. I also love the range of unexpected but super wearable colors.”

Available in six glistening tones, this tinted gloss is the ideal complement for those who prefer a gloss with a balm-like consistency. While the shades aren't super buildable—meaning you won't be able to get a ton of color density with them—they each add a hint of color that looks beautiful on minimal makeup days or layered over lipstick.

What to Look for When Buying a Lip Gloss

  • Hydrating Ingredients: Lip glosses with hydrating ingredients like hyaluronic acid, jojoba oil, and shea butter will work double duty to give your lips some shine while also providing moisture—this is especially important if you have dry lips.
  • Shade Range: Clear lip glosses are makeup collection must-haves considering that they layer beautifully over any and all lip colors, but if you want to knock out your color and shine step in one, pick a tinted gloss.
  • Finish: Lip glosses are, for the most part, glossy—we know you know that. However, there are levels to this; some offer a more muted shine while others provide a wet-looking finish that can be seen from far away. Ultimately, the finish you choose is nothing more than a matter of preference.

FAQ

  • What is the longest lasting lip gloss?

    Lip glosses fade relatively quickly, that's just the nature of the product. But if a long-lasting lip gloss is important to you, look for a formula that's rich with a bit of tackiness to it. Typically, the stickier the gloss, the longer it will last on your lips.

Why Trust Byrdie

Alyssa Kaplan is an experienced writer in the beauty industry and product tester specializing in cosmetics. She has tons of experience using lip gloss and has many of the options on this list in her personal collection. She received a bachelor’s degree from the Fashion Institute of Technology, where she studied marketing and product development in the cosmetics industry as well as fashion business marketing. Alyssa has been a commerce writer at Byrdie since 2022, where she covers all things beauty.

These 16 High-Shine Glosses Let Your Lips Take Center Stage (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Arline Emard IV

Last Updated:

Views: 6241

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (72 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arline Emard IV

Birthday: 1996-07-10

Address: 8912 Hintz Shore, West Louie, AZ 69363-0747

Phone: +13454700762376

Job: Administration Technician

Hobby: Paintball, Horseback riding, Cycling, Running, Macrame, Playing musical instruments, Soapmaking

Introduction: My name is Arline Emard IV, I am a cheerful, gorgeous, colorful, joyous, excited, super, inquisitive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.